Could the Poll be reworded?
Like: "Yes/No, there is /not/ enough evidence to show that Keldeo is deserving of a suspect test."
The way it's worded now suggest that anyone who feels it deserves a suspect feels that it is a broken, when there are a lot of users undecided. (This would also mean resetting the poll since the answers up to now / if they change are not really valid responses).
As for my thoughts on Keldeo:
Keldeo is brutal vs. offense, I should know. However, I don't get why people over exaggerate Keldeo's bulk and whatnots. Yes, it's pretty good. It can take Breloom's LO Mach and Lucario's Extreme Speed after Rocks, right? But can it take them both? Offense plays pretty fast pace, and most offense doesn't have "clear counters" to OU threats; rather, they use multiple checks and hazard pressure (or the presence of weather) to combat opposing teams, and thus Keldeo only really needs to be checked. Priority users under hazards can do this pretty well, and because Scarf Keldeo is such a late game sweeper, if you can set up before it comes in you can probably smash through it anyway.
Also, the fact that Keldeo is commonly choiced is a Pokemon that can be set up on. Others have mentioned that "you cannot set up on Keldeo," and to you I ask; why? EB Keldeo is usually not used late game whereas Scarf is, specs isn't too threatening to offensive teams so I'm not bringing that up, so if you are facing Scarf Keldeo (the one that can smash offense the most) can indeed be set up on. HP Ice locked Keldeo is pretty easy to set up on (do I really need to name Pokemon that can set up on HP Ice locked Keldeo? I would think that would be pretty simple considering how weak HP ice is) and being locked into Pump / SS respectively opens up a lot of set up opportunities for offensive pokemon respectively (Rak on HP Ice, Dnite on SS or Hydro, Gar on SS, SD Feraligatr, SD Toxicroak, etc. etc.).
While EB can prevent it being set up on (not that you'll usually set up on Keldeo, only that it's pretty viable lategame when you know what Keldeo set your facing and if it happens to be scared it is more than viable), EB Keldeo is also easily outpaced and worn down by hazards (multiple switch outs and the fact that its brought in midgame rather than late) helps beat it.
While Keldeo is a great Pokemon; to me, Keldeo is just like any other top tier threat: you play around it. I've never had much difficulty beating Keldeo with teams where I used DRAGONITE as my ONLY Keldeo check. That's right, the team I used was, on paper, pretty weak to Scarf Keldeo. And yet, I've never had problems with it, because priority and hazards and coming on in choice locked attacks is more than enough to check it. And really, offensive teams can't "counter" pokemon Terrakion, right? Nothing switches into a CB attack, so nothing is truly a safe switch (technically), and yet offensive teams manage. I feel Keldeo is similar in this regard. Offensive teams run checks to beat most of what they have to, so I don't see why people are looking for Keldeo counters when running offense. Maximum HP KyuB is a cool check; pair it up with a Breloom, put it in rain with CM Jirachi and Tornadus, and you've already got a team that's breaking a lot of the metagame while keeping Keldeo pretty moderately checked. Is that too many checks for you? How about opposing Keldeo? They're bulky enough to RK itself, Breloom is bulky enough to live SS from Scarf or EB Keldeo, and you've got Celebi that pretty much counters Keldeo.
Now to some of you, you play stall teams and offensive mumbojumbo means absolute garbage to you, right? Well, for starters, someone calced Keldeo facing and winning against Jellicent, but that calc was pretty poorly ev'd. SpD Jellicent is a pretty safe counter imo, especially since HP Ghost is not doing to much even with SR support, and I'm sure many stall players agree. Sun stall gets Cress, while other stalls get Jellicent, Ammongus, Slowbro (obviously a check since Specs Pump murders, but it's usually partnered with Amo so COME ON folks), Tentacruel, Latias, SpD Jirachi, SpD Celebi, etc. I don't really see how Keldeo can be that threatening to stall, unless your facing the pretty rare Specs Keldeo. Even then, Specs Keldeo relies on rain for Hydro Pump to be that intimidating, and it's HP Ghost arguably still isn't doing enough to derail SpD Jellicent or SpD Ammongus.
Another thing with Celebi; it can LIVE a Hidden Power Bug, which; by default, makes it at least a check to Keldeo in the regard that it can come in and force it out. Also, you all mention TTar trapping Celebi or Scizor pursuit trapping it (or using Acrobatics). I mean WTF, am I the only one running 266 spe Celebi on my Baton Pass set? It's called adjusting to the meta, and you can't risk Wash outpacing you with 265 (common speed tier for Tenta and Skarm) or Scizor with 252 outpacing you either, so I don't see really why people don't run SpD Cele with a bit more speed. Regardless, Celebi can reliably baton pass out from both Scizor and Tyranitar so they only check it imo since you can preserve Celebi long enough for Keldeo.
That's my two cents. Personally, I think it's worthy of at least suspect since it's an awesome Pokemon, but I put no on the Poll because of how Haunter worded it; since I do not think it is ban-worthy and so that outweighed me putting yes since worthy of suspect does not equal ban worthy imo. So some mod please fix that.
My views may be a bit biased due to my experiences both using and playing against Keldeo. By no right is my argument written to swing the side ban or no ban to Keldeo; only to share my expriences. I will not be arguing any of my points so if I do not respond to people quoting my post; it is not because I think you are right, but simply because I am sharing my opinion and opinions can never be changed. I will listen to what you have to say and keep it in my mind so that when I vote on Keldeo, I'll remember anything said. However, I am not arguing since it will be utterly pointless.
Good day! :)
EDIT: Can't Jellicent just WoW CB Tar? I'm sure Pursuit is pretty weak when burned. And any Jellicent outsped by TTar should be running speed evs to outpace it, no? (I don't use Jellicent much, just speculating).
Rey: I don't think (or want) to imply that Keldeo ISN'T bulky; only that it isn't as great as some users claim it to be. Starmie has fighting resist typing and gets recovery in recover and lefties, whereas Keldeo doesn't really run leftovers or get Recover so I digress.