1) I said it was a problem for almost all pokemon. On another note, defensive Politoed all use Boil Over because the burn chance> extra damage on a defensive set.
My point here was that Politoed is out-classed at offensive and defensive roles. The only reason to use it is Drizzle.
2) Offensive rain is not nearly as good without Swift Swim. But without double STAB, it sucks. So let's look at pokemon who get double STAB and Thunder. Starmie, Lanturn, Lapras, Rotom-W. So we have two viable pokemon (Starmie and Rotom-W) that get both. If rain offense is carried on by just those two pokemon, we might as well put it out of its misery.
3) You know, its funny. I actually said that normal=/=water in my post.
The reason that comparison works is Download. Porygon-Z is very similar to Swift Swim sweepers. Very powerful, very frail, and gets an extra 1.5x boost (assuming Download gives you the Sp Atk). However, even with the Download boost, Porygon-Z cannot sweep because it is too slow and frail (like all the Swift Swimmers). It would need doubled speed to sweep.
Porygon2 is similar to the "bulky offense" that you said rain offense would become. You said it would become pokemon who can get double STAB and take hit. Porygon2 can take a hit and it gets a 1.5x boost (once again, assuming Download gives it that). However, even with bulk and the extra boost, Porygon2 wouldn't make the best sweeper. It simply can't dish out the damage.
Should I use my Jolteon/Snorlax example again? Water=/=Normal.
But if you look anywhere else in the metagame, you'll see that the kind of thing you're talking about doesn't work that way.
4) I know there are. But just because Politoed can survive a Close Combat, it's not the end-all be-all of pokemon. Hundreds of pokemon can survive a Close Combat. Your thing about Close Combat made no sense.
My post wasn't even about weaknesses/resistances. It was about your illogical Close Combat thing.
edit because of your edit: Politoed being bulky doesn't make it OU material. Lickilicky is bulky but it's not that great. The only reason to ever use Politoed is Drizzle. Without that, it doesn't deserve a spot. Simple as that.
5) Yes, it is about tiering. But I wasn't talking about it then.
I said "Rain offense without Swift Swim would not be like Gen4 Rain offense."
Then you said "Gen4 doesn't relate to tiering"
So I'm asking, how does tiering relate to my statement at all? How?
6) With no Drizzle and no Sandstorm, how on earth does Politoed become better than Tyranitar? Tyranitar has better stats in 4 of the 6. They tie in 1 of the 6. Rock is a worse defensive type than Water. But Tyranitar is also able to use Stealth Rock, which Politoed cannot.
How you think that Politoed is better than Tyranitar escapes me. I fail to see your logic.
And I never said Politoed was bad. I said it wasn't worth a spot unless you make your team around it.
7) The metagame "must" not do anything. In theory, we could decide to not ban anything else and just deal with all the broken stuff.
We wouldn't do that, but to try and point the metagame toward some ideal is not right. We ban what's broken, and see where it gets us.
But Porygon-Z and Politoed weren't even being compared. So to start comparing makes no sense.
1) And i think that Drizzle is a good reason for using it so i don´t see the problem, and you can say that there isn´t a reason for using Drizzle Politoed without Swift Swim but we haven´t tested it so we don´t know.
2) There are even good pokemons that aren´t water types but can make use of the water attack boost (the double STAB isn´t the only part of the water offensive), and Thunder as coverage move, and some pokemons can be water types without Thunder but they can even be good (Kingdra without SwiftSwim, for example), and as i have said we haven´t tested how rain can work without Swift Swim.
3) Porygon-Z don´t represent all the SwiftSwimmer and even less represent all the rain sweepers that aren´t SwiftSwimmers (the samething goes for Porygon2), it´s sure that Kingdra will be OU in anyway, it can DD and become a powerful sweeper (not broken but it can knock somethings out), and if you think that the other SwiftSwimmer will be used if you ban Drizzle instead of baning Swift Swim i can ensure you that no, they won´t, now, we can have too Cloyster, Toxicroak, Zapdos and some offensive Tentacruel, Kerudio, Rotom-W and in a lesser extent Jolteon, Magnezone, Lati@s, Voltrolos, Dragonite, Gengar, Gyarados, etc. that can make a good usage of rain even without SwiftSwim (and not all needs both, water attacks and Thunder/Gale for it), and nearly none of these are like Porygon-Z or Porygon2 in nothing.
4) I´ve explained you my example, CC isn´t the only 120 bp. attack, and Lickilicky is bulky but it haven´t a good typing and Porygon2 have recovery, better stats and a better ability so it is a better normal-type wall.
5) Yes, rain offense without Swift Swim would not be like Gen 4th Rain offense, Is this what you want to hear? Okay, i´ve said it, now, What is the idea of all it?.
6) I´m too wondering of how can be Politoed more used than Tyranitar, it just can occurs in a weatherless version of a metagame dominated by steel types (Nattorei) and fighting types (Roopushin/Blaziken), oh wait...!, now speaking seriously, the idea of that Politoed is worth for a slot only in a team around it, is logic, but SwiftSwim isn´t the only thing that makes rain useful.
7) The idea of all these bans is making a better metagame and we can take many decisions for it, we are now debating the best decision, and if you think that Chlorophyll can work in a balanced metagame, then it is your opinion but i think that Chlorophyll is equal and even worst than SwiftSwim (and perhaps it is not very notorius now but assuming that we ban Drizzle or SwiftSwim, then it can become a problem, and i think that the best solution for it is baning SwiftSwim/SandThrow/Chlorophyll instead of baning auto-weather, i think that it will early balance the metagame, and perhaps we must test it, and how you can see i´m not the first that think it).
8) Perhaps you weren´t comparing Politoed with Porygon-Z, but the idea of all it is that i think that the double STAB of Politoed (and other things that it have) are enough dangerous for condering it a worth threat for OU, and even more if it too mean other x1.5 bonus to the water attacks of other pokemons on your team (and really, you have been arguing about Porygon-Z/Politoed with me for long time even when you haven´t said it first so i think that it is officially part of the discussion).