can we all please be intelligent and learn what the definition of counter is
A counter is defined as a Pokemon that can switch into another Pokemon and win EVERY TIME, barring hax. Nihilego is clearly not a counter to Landorus-t because Landorus-T can easily OHKO it with Earthquake. As a result, HP Ice Nihilego is a soft CHECK to Landorus-T, because it wins only if:
- given a free switch to Landorus-T
- switching in as Landorus-T goes for Stealth Rock (bad play)
First of all, this discussion that you two are having is generally unrelated to the viability rankings and is a tangent of the Terrakion vs. Nihilego discussion. Most of the time I try and be generally nice but this "check/counter" talk is directed at
hecatomb. Man, you overuse the word counter in your arguments and a lot of the time your arguments are unrelated to what is going on in the viability rankings. Please, read all of the posts and try to only post relevant things. This last part is not only directed at you, but at everyone who has made this thread a little bit difficult for me to read.
Now, my opinions:
Celesteela > S: Disagree: In a meta with a lot of extremely centralizing Pokemon, I consider S-rank to be those centralizing Pokemon. Greninja, Landorus-T, and Mega Metagross are all extremely centralizing. While Celesteela has a multitude of defensive and offensive achievements, it certainly has its fair share of cons. Celesteela lacks power when running Autotomize Flyinium Z, and is difficult to snowball with when running Life Orb. Defensive Celesteela is taken advantage of by multiple centralizing metagame threats, mainly Rockium Lando and Zygarde, which have become more popular, and I find myself running Tpunch Metagross more and more. A very good mon, but not one that is on the level of Landorus-T and Megagross (who threaten legitimately every team that doesn't have Bronzong) or Greninja (who's versatility and threat of being Ash-Gren make it ridiculously difficult to play around).
I agree with every other nomination that Colonel M made. Notably:
Thundurus-T > B-: Strongly agree: Some people say this is bad but by bad do you mean on par with a Pokemon that is legitimately only worth using on Sticky Web teams (Xurkitree) or one that simply is never worth using (Mega Garchomp)? Any mon with BoltBeam coverage is good right now to pick apart LandoFini cores, and this one is particularly good because DD Electrium Z sets up on typically Electric checks (AV Growth etc.). Definitely not a mon worth using all the time, but it is much better than every other mon in C and C+.
Terrakion should stay B+, its scarf set pressures common fighting checks a lot and although it faces a lot of competition from nihilego I find its STAB combination much more threatening in a metagame where MGross is on a ton of teams. Once again because its scarf set pressures common fighting checks a ton (Lando, Fini, Amoonguss) it is a really good Fighting-spam mon and with a partner like Keldeo it is extremely effective. I think you were way too hard on it. Finally Gyarados should rise but I have nothing else to add that hasn't already been said.
oh also the text in b- is bigger than the rest of the text and it bothers me like fuck lmao
My Own Noms:
Bronzong > B: This mon is really good glue right now and it is much better than any of the shit in B-, it sucks that it is a passive rocker but just the fact that it checks so many threats and sets rocks effectively for balance makes it b- alone imo. The fact that those mons happen to include the best mon in the metagame, the second best and most splashable mon in the metagame (including its broken sets), and plenty more A-rank mons makes it B.
MSharpedo > B+. This mon is an insane cleaner on offense and its Crunch is such a nightmare for other offense to beat. Although it is frail, it resists a lot of common priority moves (Water Shuriken, BP) and outspeeds most of the unboosted AND boosted metagame at +1. The nature of offense right now makes it really weak to sharpedo and I think this should be reflected more accurately in the viability rankings.