1. Aegislash is not remotely overpowered and old how anyone could ever come to the conclusion that he is. He isnt in Galar OU so it doesnt make sense that he is here. The other mons ppl are trying to kill you can understand their argument but calling SubToxic OP and centralizing is kinda silly. He has plenty of countsrplay, most notably significantly decreased bulk, horrenderous speed, no recovery, walled by a significant portion of the tier. I dont even get how someone could seriously say Aegislash is ban worthy lol. Hes a great mon but hes not banworthy.
... 1.a. He certainly is Galar OU, and he's very high in the VR in spite of Dragapult being on every 3rd team and Hydreigon being everywhere. I don't know where you got this from.
b. Sub Toxic isn't OP. It's the way it lets Aegi uses it to cheese all the mons that check its other sets. Including the "significant proportion of the tier" you mention.
c. The bulk drop is fairly small, the speed is fixed by Autonomise sets and Shadow Sneak. And btw, low speed is often a boon for it since it stays in shield form when taking hits.
d. No recovery has never been an issue for Lando-T or Magearna.
e.
https://www.smogon.com/forums/threa...islash-remains-in-ubers.3536089/#post-6172079 I quote:
I'm all for this! Yes thank you based Haunter. You are very based. ... I'm for this suspect and hope to see it in ou.
#FREEAEGISLASH2015
Sincerely, Omari P
UPDATE AS OF APRIL 23rd : FUCK AEGI I WAS WRONG GET THIS DUDE OUT OF OU OMG.. it's not him personally but his presence makes broken cores possible
And many others like it. You might argue things have changed since then. The King's Shield nerf. More potential checks. But name a mon that deals with Double Dance, Banded, Specs AND Sub Toxic in one set. The first few are handleable. But I think you fail to appreciate how important it is to have checks that beat things reliably (as also shown by your lack of understanding of the Zy ban). Aegi with Toxic available to it is just not a mon you can check from Team Preview. And that's not a good thing. I would be most open to a resuspect once we've cleaned the tier out a bit, so we can clarify exactly how much the nerfs hurt it, but for now the tier needs urgent stabilising.
2. Agree. See also Scarf Dragapult.
3. ... Are we talking about the same mon here???
a. Thousand Arrows alone makes Zy pretty nutty. It has 1 switch-in in the tier-Bulu. The ability to just ignore the type chart on an already powerful offensive typing and have 90 BP on it is so stupid. It means Zy only needs 1 attacking move, and the other 3 slots can be literally anything.
b. Which bulky grasses do you refer to? Only Bulu and Ferro got above the usage threshold, and Ferro is part-steel, so it doesn't like Thousand Arrows at all.
c. Zy doesn't need recovery thanks to its amazing defenses and typing. If it is running a slower build, leftovers+its switch-in Bulu giving it Grassy Terrain is loads of recovery, especially considering it comes in on Volt Switch for free. Oh, and Thousand Arrows being stupid means Rest Talk is actually a thing on this mon.
d. Slow-has the same base speed as Hydreigon and Garm what are you on. Doesn't hit hard-100 base ATK. Are you looking at the same mon as me? Sure, they aren't "broken" stats but they're more than enough for what it has to do.
e. Predictable-This is exactly what he isn't. This is why he is worth the banhammer.
f. Tons of things pressure Mega Kanga too. Shall we unban that? Yes, Zy has offensive checks, but none of them can switch into him. None.
g. Loses to rain and sun-really? And those are everywhere rn. Not. The fact you name Tang when Zy in fact beats it with Toxic is hilarious. And Clef can't switch into Thousand Arrows and Unaware hates Toxic.
h. Lando-T can't beat Grasses and Flying mons without a Z-move.
Read this:
https://www.smogon.com/forums/threa...thousand-miles-zygarde-is-now-banned.3645049/
4. Yep. We told you so.
5. Yes.
6. Why? Who really cares? It's probably garbage if we do unban it. We have Lele and Magearna. Besides, Timid Eruption Heatran we could at least say would be a thing in Gen 8. That would not.
7. Yes.
Zyg wasnt even OP in gen 7, he was just big cancer.
Whether or not he still is big cancer comes down to how common the glare+setup set ends up being. Thankfully it isnt common at all at the moment.
You mean people don't run Glare???
Whistles quietly.